| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 17 2025 | Air Force at San Diego State (San Diego State -24.5) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Arizona State at UCLA (UCLA -10) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Creighton at Xavier (Creighton +3) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Eastern Washington vs Washington State (Washington State -6.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Georgetown at Marquette (Georgetown +6.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | James Madison at Old Dominion (James Madison -3) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Louisiana vs Delaware (Delaware +3) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Loyola Chicago at San Francisco (San Francisco -12) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Mercyhurst at Syracuse (Syracuse -25) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | North Texas at Santa Clara (Santa Clara -12) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | Old Dominion vs South Florida (Old Dominion +3.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Richmond at Elon (Elon +3.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | Sam Houston at Oregon State (Oregon State -6.5) | loss |
| Dec 17 2025 | South Florida at Alabama (South Florida +14.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 17 2025 | UCSB at Green Bay (UCSB -6.5) | loss |
|