| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 24 2025 | California vs Hawaii (California +1.5) | loss |
| Dec 23 2025 | Harvard at St Johns (St Johns -26) | PUSH |
| Dec 23 2025 | Idaho at CS Bakersfield (CS Bakersfield +7.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 23 2025 | Lindenwood at Missouri State (Missouri State -3.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 23 2025 | Morgan State at LMU (LMU -24) | WINNER |
| Dec 23 2025 | Toledo vs Louisville (Toledo +12) | WINNER |
| Dec 23 2025 | UC Riverside at UCLA (UCLA -24) | WINNER |
| Dec 23 2025 | UCF at Florida Atlantic (UCF -8.5) | loss |
| Dec 23 2025 | UNLV at Ohio (UNLV -6.5) | loss |
| Dec 23 2025 | Villanova at Seton Hall (Villanova Even) | WINNER |
| Dec 23 2025 | Western Kentucky vs Southern Mississippi (Western Kentucky +2.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Bethune Cookman at Arizona (Arizona -39) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Davidson at Kansas (Kansas -15) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Eastern Michigan at Wright State (Wright State -10.5) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Eastern Washington at BYU (BYU -35) | loss |
|