| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Sep 29 2023 | Cincinnati at BYU (BYU -1) | WINNER |
| Sep 29 2023 | LA Tech at UTEP (UTEP +2) | loss |
| Sep 29 2023 | Louisville at NC State (NC State +3.5) | WINNER |
| Sep 29 2023 | Utah at Oregon State (Oregon State -4) | WINNER |
| Sep 28 2023 | Jacksonville State at Sam Houston State (Jacksonville State -7) | PUSH |
| Sep 28 2023 | Middle Tennessee St at Western Kentucky (Western Kentucky -6.5) | WINNER |
| Sep 28 2023 | Temple at Tulsa (Tulsa -3) | WINNER |
| Sep 23 2023 | AppalachianState at Wyoming (AppalachianState +3) | PUSH |
| Sep 23 2023 | Arizona at Stanford (Stanford +13) | WINNER |
| Sep 23 2023 | Army at Syracuse (Syracuse -13) | PUSH |
| Sep 23 2023 | Auburn at Texas AM (Texas AM -9.5) | WINNER |
| Sep 23 2023 | BYU at Kansas (BYU +9) | loss |
| Sep 23 2023 | California at Washington (Washington -20.5) | WINNER |
| Sep 23 2023 | Charlotte at Florida (Florida -29) | loss |
| Sep 23 2023 | Colorado at Oregon (Oregon -21) | WINNER |
|